| Year | Most Valuable Player | Pitcher of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Heart & Hustle Award | Play Off MVP * |
| 2023 | Jamie Perebzak | Carter Liske | Carter Liske | Anthony Owen | Anthony Owen |
| 2022 | Jamie Perebzak | Logan Blumhagen | Jamie Perebzak | Anthony Owen | |
| 2021 | Will Gardner | Craig Tomas | Will Gardner | Hunter Lawrence-Carr | Anthony Owen |
| 2020 | No Awards - COVID-19 | ||||
| 2019 | Evan Hoffman | Logan Blumhagen | Tylor Jans | Anthony Owen | |
| 2018 | Connor Bronson | Craig Tomas | Ty Wagar | Anthony Owen | |
| 2017 | Craig Tomas | Jared Roddelt | Damian Obrigewitch | Luc Riopel | |
| 2016 | Dan Curtis | Craig Tomas | M. Brisson/K. Czarnecki | Darren Adams | |
| 2015 | Evan Hoffman | Craig Tomas | Brad Macuch | Justin Lovig | |
| 2014 | J. McHugh/C. Tomas | Craig Tomas | Evan Hoffman | Darren Adams | |
| 2013 | Dan Curtis | Craig Tomas | Josh Kennedy | Brad Wolansky | |
| 2012 | Joe Carr | Craig Tomas | Kyle Hesse | ||
| 2011 | Craig Tomas | Sean Maguire | Kyle Hesse | K. Hardman/D. Dallorto | |
| 2010 | Jessy Beley | Derek Dallorto | Jessy Beley | Kevin Hardman | |
| 2009 (Senior) | Derek Dallorto | Derek Dallorto | Mike Poelzer | Kevin Hardman | |
| 2009 (Junior) | Myles Ethier | Myles Ethier | Evan Olsen | Taylor Lavallee | |
| 2008 (Senior) | Brad Wolansky | Derek Dallorto | Brian Bratushesky | Darren Kirstiuk | |
| 2008 (Junior) | Dan McDonald | Darren Adams | Myles Shaw | Jessy Beley | |
| 2007 | Danny Mikitka | Sean Maguire | Ian MacMillan | ||
| 2006 | Ian MacMillan | Craig Tomas | Chris Hartmann | Kevin Hardman | |
| 2005 (Senior) | Kurtus Millar | David Ross | Ian MacMillan | Jason Bjornson | |
| 2005 (Junior) | Darren Lamble | Chris Hartmann | Miles Walker | Cam White | |
| 2004 (Senior - Black) | Danny Mikitka | Craig Tomas | Matt Rindero | Jason Bjornson | |
| 2004 (Senior - White) | Brad Kuhn | Chad Marchand | Kelsey Tomyn | Bruce Rau | |
| 2004 (Junior) | Matt Patrick | Reid Baker | Devery Van de Keer | Shane Husar | |
*not always awarded